What Size of Kidney Stone Requires Surgery?

If you or someone you care about is dealing with kidney stones, it’s important to know what size of kidney stones require surgery. Kidney stones can be very painful, and whether you need surgery usually depends on how big the stone is. Stones that are larger than 20 mm in the kidney or 10 mm in the ureter usually need surgery to be removed. Smaller stones often pass on their own without surgery.

This guide will walk you through thresholds, treatment options, symptoms, and prevention strategies. With clear insights, you’ll learn how to manage kidney stones and stay proactive about your health.

Key Points

• Kidney stones are measured in millimeters using CT (computed tomography) scans or ultrasounds

• Renal stones <20 mm (SWL or URS); > 20 mm (PCNL)

• Ureteral stones: <10 mm (observation); >10 mm (surgery)

• Symptoms like pain or infection may necessitate surgery regardless of size

• Prevention includes hydration, diet changes; 50% recurrence rate

What Size of Kidney Stone Requires Surgery?

Surgery, particularly percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL), is required in kidney stones that are >20 mm.

Kidney stones can be a very painful ordeal. Their size often determines whether you need surgery. Larger stones >20 mm require surgery while smaller stones may pass naturally without intervention or with less invasive treatments.

Kidney stones are hard deposits composed of minerals and salts that form in your kidneys or ureters. They vary in size from a grain of sand to the size of a golf ball. Their size will directly affect what treatment options are offered to you.

• Why size matters—larger stones can obstruct your urine from flowing. They may cause pain, infections, or kidney damage

• Appropriate use of scans should be employed to determine the accuracy of size

Knowing when surgery is needed helps you make informed choices.

How Are Kidney Stones Sized and Measured?

Kidney stones are usually measured by their width (in millimeters) using imaging tests, like CT (computed tomography) scans, X-rays, or ultrasounds. The size of the stone helps doctors decide the best treatment.

The most accurate and the gold-standard way to measure a kidney stone is with a CT scan. CT scans can show even very small stones and give a clear picture of their size, shape, and location. The stone’s size is usually described in millimeters (mm). For example:

• Less than 5 mm: Small and likely to pass on their own

• 5–10 mm: Might need help to pass or may require treatment (however, 50% of cases with this size may pass out naturally)

• Larger than 10 mm: Often needs surgery or another procedure

Other imaging methods include:

• Ultrasound—Safe and radiation-free but may miss small stones

• X-ray (KUB X-ray)—Good for larger stones, but not all stones show up clearly

Doctors use these measurements to figure out if the stone can pass naturally or if treatment is needed. They may also check the stone’s location in the kidney or urinary tract, which can affect how easily it passes. Knowing the approximate size of the kidney stones can help you understand your treatment options.

Size Thresholds for Renal Stones

The size thresholds for renal stones give a general idea of when stones might pass on their own and when medical help is needed.

• <5 mm: These are usually small enough to pass naturally through the urinary tract without surgery.

• Between 5 mm and 10 mm: These stones may pass on their own but often cause pain or blockage.

• >10 mm (1 centimeter): Stones this size are unlikely to pass without intervention.

• >20 mm: Very large stones usually require more invasive surgery because they are unlikely to break down or pass on their own.

The 20 mm size is an important point for deciding treatment. Stones bigger than this usually do not pass on their own. They often need surgery to be removed safely.

The location of the stone in the kidney also affects treatment. Stones in the lower part of the kidney might need different methods, even if they are the right size for simpler treatments.

Size Thresholds for Ureteral Stones

Ureteral stones have different size rules because they are found in the narrow tubes that connect the kidneys to the bladder. These tubes are called ureters. Since the space in the ureter is very tight, the size of the stone is very important when deciding how to treat it.

It generally follows similar thresholds as with the kidney stones except for the maximum, which is 15 mm. This size almost never passes out naturally. Your doctor knows that as the size increases, it also decreases the likelihood of the stone being passed out.

When Surgery Is Recommended for Kidney Stone Regardless of Size?

Sometimes, surgery is needed even for small kidney stones that could usually pass on their own. In emergencies, doctors choose surgery to keep the patient safe instead of waiting for the stone to pass naturally.

Immediate surgical intervention is recommended for:

• Infection with obstruction—may be recurrent that can cause hydronephrosis (swelling of the kidney)

• Completely blocks urine flow

• Severe pain (not controlled with medications)—may result in nausea and vomiting

• Persistent bleeding

• Kidney function decline

• Underlying kidney disease

You should always keep your doctor informed about any sudden or new changes in your symptoms.

What Are the Treatment Options for Different Sizes of Kidney Stones?

Treatment approaches for kidney stones vary widely and depend on several key factors, with stone size being one of the most critical. The following sections will explore the full range of treatment options, starting with conservative strategies for small stones and progressing to more invasive procedures for larger or more complex cases.

Non-Surgical Treatments for Small Stones

As previously discussed, smaller-sized stones (under 5mm) often pass naturally with appropriate care and support. This could include lifestyle modifications. These conservative approaches often prevent any surgical risk while allowing natural stone passage.

Conservative management includes:

• Increased fluid intake—2-3 L of fluid a day helps flush stones

• Pain management—over-the-counter medications may be used to reduce or alleviate the discomfort

• Medical therapy—alpha-blockers may be used in some cases to relax the ureters

• Dietary modifications—reduce sodium and oxalate-rich foods

• Exercise—gentle movement helps flush the stones out

About 90% of stones <5 mm can pass out naturally. Conversely a staggering 95% of stones >8mm are likely going to get impacted and eventually require intervention.

Watchful waiting often involves regular monitoring of the stone. It can be done through imaging and symptom tracking. You will often get clear instructions from your doctor on what signs to monitor, particularly those needing immediate intervention.

Minimally Invasive Procedures for Medium-Sized Stones

Mid-sized kidney stones (5-10mm) often benefit from minimally-invasive procedures. This avoids major surgery while ensuring that stone-removal is effective. More often, these techniques have excellent success rates and shorter recovery times.

Extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy (ESWL) uses focused sound waves that break stones into smaller fragments so they can pass out naturally. This can be done in an outpatient setting.

ESWL success rates vary according to their baseline size. Nonetheless, a study found 65.8% success rates in stones ranging from 3-20 mm. In another study, 53% of patients were stone-free after just 2 weeks.

Surgical Options for Large Stones

Large stones >20 mm typically require percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL). This is the most effective treatment for complex stones. It involves creating small incisions in the back to access the kidneys directly. It is considered to be the first-line of treatment for large stones.

PCNL offers several advantages for large stones, including:

• Relatively high success rates—70.5-95%

• Often employed as a single procedure

• Flexible and versatile (for different stone locations)

• Stone analysis (complete removal of stones to analyze composition)

You may be required to get hospitalized for about 1-2 days since general anesthesia is administered. The recovery period is about 2-4 weeks.

PCNL has been the treatment preferred for kidney stones. The procedure has evolved over the years and could reach high success rates compared to other approaches.

What Are the Symptoms That Indicate Surgery Might Be Needed?

Surgical treatment for kidney stones may be necessary regardless of size when certain complications arise. These symptoms indicate that conservative management is no longer sufficient:

• Severe, Uncontrolled Pain

• Pain not relieved by standard medications

• Pain that significantly disrupts daily life

• Persistent or Heavy Blood in Urine

• Bleeding lasting more than 24–48 hours

• May indicate injury to the urinary tract

• Signs of Infection (Medical Emergency)

• Fever and chills

• Cloudy or foul-smelling urine

• Often requires urgent surgical treatment

• Urinary Obstruction

• Inability to urinate

• Noticeably reduced urine output

• Persistent Nausea and Vomiting

• Prevents adequate fluid intake

• Can lead to dehydration and worsening symptoms

The presence of multiple symptoms typically suggests a more serious condition. This increases the likelihood of requiring surgical intervention. Immediate medical evaluation is strongly recommended in these cases.

How to Prevent Kidney Stones from Growing Large Enough to Require Surgery?

Prevention strategies often focus on lifestyle changes that will reduce stone formation risk. It will also prevent the existing stones from growing larger that may need surgical intervention.

Some of the strategies include:

• Adequate hydration—aim for 2.5-3L of water per day; dilutes urine and stone-forming substances

• Dietary modification

• Reduction of salt (sodium) intake—at least 2,300 mg per day

• Adequate calcium intake through food sources

• Consume lean protein in moderation

• Minimize oxalate-rich foods such as spinach and nuts

• Increase citrate-containing fruits or taking citrate supplements

About 50% of kidney stone cases are expected to recur within 5 years, which would increase without prevention strategies in dietary habits and lifestyle.

Medical intervention is reserved for people who have recurrent stone issues or specific metabolic conditions. These treatments deal with underlying factors that increase the risk for stone formation.

You should always follow-up when recommended by your medical provider. Professional advice to prevent kidney stones and even reduce stone recurrence risk.

Related Resources:

What is Atrophic Kidney? When the Body Filters Begin to Fail

7-Day Kidney Stone Diet Chart: Why is it Important?

Quick Summary Box

• Kidney stones are measured in millimeters using CT scans or ultrasounds to determine treatment approach

• Renal stones ≤20mm can be treated with ESWL or ureteroscopy; stones >20mm require PCNL surgery

• Ureteral stones ≤10mm may pass naturally; larger stones typically need surgical intervention

• Surgery may be required regardless of size if stones cause infection, obstruction, or uncontrollable pain

• Prevention through hydration and dietary changes is crucial since 50% of patients experience recurrence within 5 years

• Recovery time varies from 1-2 weeks for ESWL to 4-6 weeks for PCNL depending on procedure complexity

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the different types of kidney stone surgeries?

Types include ESWL (shock wave lithotripsy), ureteroscopy, and PCNL (percutaneous nephrolithotomy), chosen based on stone size and location. ESWL uses sound waves to break stones from outside the body. Ureteroscopy, on the other hand, involves inserting a scope through the urinary tract to remove stones directly. And, PCNL requires a small incision in the back to access larger stones that can't be treated with other methods.

Can kidney stones recur after surgery?

Yes, about 50% of cases recur in five years. This is especially true if diet and lifestyle changes have not been made, or any efforts to prevent recurrence therein.

How long does it take to recover from kidney stone surgery?

Recovery from kidney stone surgery varies depending on the procedure. Prevention is key through lifestyle modifications including adequate hydration, dietary changes, and regular medical follow-up. You are still at risk of developing kidney stones even after you have surgery, especially if you have underlying factors.

References

Al- zubi, M., Al Sleibi, A., Elayan, B. M., Al-issawi, S. Z., Bani-hani, M., Alsharei, A., AlSmadi, J., abualhaj, S., & Ibrahim, A. Y. (2021). The effect of stone and patient characteristics in predicting extra-corporal shock wave lithotripsy success rate: A cross sectional study. Annals of Medicine and Surgery, 70, 102829. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amsu.2021.102829 

Brisbane, W., Bailey, M., & Sorensen, M. (2016). An overview of kidney stone imaging techniques. Nature Reviews Urology, 13(11), 654–662. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrurol.2016.154 

EAU Guidelines on Urolithiasis - GUIDELINES - Uroweb. (n.d.). Uroweb - European Association of Urology. https://uroweb.org/guidelines/urolithiasis/chapter/guidelines 

Ganpule, A. P., Vijayakumar, M., Malpani, A., & Desai, M. R. (2016). Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) a critical review. International Journal of Surgery, 36, 660–664. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsu.2016.11.028 

Hamdy Aboutaleb, Omar, M., Salem, S., & Elshazly, M. (2016). Management of upper ureteral stones exceeding 15 mm in diameter: Shock wave lithotripsy versus semirigid ureteroscopy with holmium:yttrium–aluminum–garnet laser lithotripsy. SAGE Open Medicine, 4, 205031211668518-205031211668518. https://doi.org/10.1177/2050312116685180 

Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care. (2019, February 28). Treatment options for kidney stones. Nih.gov; Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK348939/ 

John Hopkins Medicine. (2019). Extracorporeal Shock Wave Lithotripsy (ESWL). Johns Hopkins Medicine Health Library. https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/conditions-and-diseases/kidney-stones/extracorporeal-shock-wave-lithotripsy-eswl 

Kidney Stones: Surgical Management Guideline - American Urological Association. (n.d.). Www.auanet.org. https://www.auanet.org/guidelines-and-quality/guidelines/kidney-stones-surgical-management-guideline 

Leslie, S. W., Sajjad, H., & Murphy, P. B. (2024). Renal calculi, nephrolithiasis. Nih.gov; StatPearls Publishing. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK442014/ 

Patti, L., & Leslie, S. W. (2021). Acute Renal Colic. PubMed; StatPearls Publishing. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK431091/ 

Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy. (2022, October 19). Cleveland Clinic. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/17349-percutaneous-nephrolithotomy 

Six Easy Ways to Prevent Kidney Stones. (2024). Kidney.org. https://www.kidney.org/kidney-topics/six-easy-ways-to-prevent-kidney-stones 

Takazawa, R. (2015). Appropriate kidney stone size for ureteroscopic lithotripsy: When to switch to a percutaneous approach. World Journal of Nephrology, 4(1), 111. https://doi.org/10.5527/wjn.v4.i1.111 

Vicentini, F. C., Gomes, C. M., Danilovic, A., Neto, E. A. C., Mazzucchi, E., & Srougi, M. (2009). Percutaneous nephrolithotomy: Current concepts. Indian Journal of Urology : IJU : Journal of the Urological Society of India, 25(1), 4–10. https://doi.org/10.4103/0970-1591.44281